California Court of Appeal: anti-SLAPP motion cannot strike a physician's whole complaint when claims based on unprotected discipline remain (Peros v. The Permanente Medical Group)
Published November 15, 2026 · Coverage November 8–14, 2026, Pacific · Lower priority
In an opinion filed November 13, the First District Court of Appeal, Division Four, affirmed a trial court's refusal to strike the entire complaint of James Peros, a physician and former shareholder of The Permanente Medical Group (TPMG), under the anti-SLAPP (strategic lawsuit against public participation) statute (Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16). The court held that claims resting only on allegations of unprotected activity are not subject to the statute's second step even if the defendant argues they are legally insufficient. Under Bonni v. St. Joseph Health System (2021), the patient-care restriction, termination recommendation and terminations Peros challenges were treated as unprotected acts, so the court declined to strike his retaliation and discrimination claims based on those acts.
Background
Peros sued after TPMG restricted him from patient care in October 2021 pending an investigation of alleged drug use, recommended termination in May 2022 and later treated him as having accepted the restriction when he refused to answer questions at the peer review hearing. His complaint includes whistleblower retaliation under Labor Code section 1102.5 and discrimination claims.
Who this affects
Hospitals and medical groups that restrict, investigate or terminate physicians, and their legal and medical staff offices.
Why it matters
Inference: where a physician's retaliation or discrimination claims rest only on unprotected disciplinary acts such as a patient-care restriction or termination, an anti-SLAPP motion is unlikely to end the suit at step two; the court did not decide whether the claims will succeed, and the merits of documented, non-retaliatory reasons for restrictions and terminations then carry the defense.
Recommended action
- Brief medical staff and employed-physician leadership that, where a claim rests only on unprotected disciplinary acts, an anti-SLAPP motion may not dispose of it, so contemporaneous documentation of the reasons matters if the claim is litigated on the merits.
Scope and timing
- Authority status
- Other (Court of Appeal opinion, certified for partial publication, affirming the trial court's anti-SLAPP ruling)
- Responsible owner
- Legal; Medical Staff Office
- Other dates
- Opinion filed November 13, 2026; certified for partial publication (part II not published).
Not established
Part II of the opinion (individual allegations, including peer review conduct) is not certified for publication. The court did not decide whether Peros's claims will succeed.
Sources
Complete edition and supplemental material
This article in the complete report →
Executive triage, source-coverage limitations, context and forward horizons remain in the complete report.
Read the entire Compliance Sweep report →