California regulator tells health plans how downcoding must be disclosed and reviewed, with plan filings due November 23
Published November 15, 2026 · Coverage November 8–14, 2026, Pacific · Medium priority
On October 23, 2026, the California Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) issued All Plan Letter (APL) 26-015 to all licensed health care service plans on downcoding, which the letter defines as paying a claim at a less complex or lower level of service than the provider billed. Plans must disclose the criteria and methods they use to pick claims for downcoding and to set the adjusted level, must review all supplemental documentation the provider submitted, which may include medical records, before downcoding, and must pay the portion of a claim the documentation supports. Each plan that has implemented or seeks to implement downcoding must make one compliance filing with DMHC by November 23, 2026.
Background
The Knox-Keene Act and DMHC's claims rules (California Code of Regulations, title 28, Rule 1300.71) require plans to pay a complete claim within 30 calendar days, to disclose their payment policies and coding methods to providers on written request, and to tell providers how to dispute a claim adjustment. The letter says downcoding is not expressly prohibited by the Act, and applies those existing rules to it.
Who this affects
Hospitals, physician groups and other providers that bill health plans licensed by the California Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC), their revenue-cycle, coding and managed-care contracting teams, and medical groups that adjudicate claims as a plan's delegate.
Why it matters
Providers gain a stated basis to ask each DMHC-licensed plan for its downcoding criteria, to expect the plan to read submitted records before reducing a claim level, and to expect payment of the supported portion instead of a whole-claim withhold. For providers acting only as submitting providers the letter adds no duty; an entity that adjudicates claims as a plan's delegate falls under the plan's responsibility for its delegates' compliance. The plan filings are not public in this letter, so how individual plans respond was not established.
Required actions
- Health plans that have implemented or seek to implement downcoding: submit one eFiling, an Amendment titled APL 26-015 Downcoding Compliance, to DMHC by November 23, 2026.
- Medical groups and other entities that adjudicate claims as a plan's delegate: the plan remains responsible for ensuring that they comply with the letter.
Recommended action
- Ask each DMHC-licensed plan, in writing, for the payment policies, rules and coding methods it uses for downcoding, as Rule 1300.71(o)(2) provides.
- Track claims paid at a lower level than billed by plan, and use the plan's provider dispute process with supporting documentation where the record supports the billed level.
- If your organization adjudicates claims as a plan's delegate, compare your own level-of-service adjustments with the letter, since the plan remains responsible for its delegates' compliance.
Scope and timing
- Authority status
- Guidance
- Responsible owner
- Revenue Cycle; Coding; Managed Care Contracting
- Publication date
- 2026-10-23
- Compliance date
- 2026-11-23
- Other dates
- November 23, 2026 is the date for each plan's compliance filing to DMHC; the letter sets no date for providers.
Not established
How individual plans responded in their filings was not established. The letter does not say whether it applies to Medi-Cal managed care plans' delegated claims in any different way.
Sources
Complete edition and supplemental material
This article in the complete report →
Executive triage, source-coverage limitations, context and forward horizons remain in the complete report.
Read the entire Compliance Sweep report →