OIG audit: CMS oversight missed most Medicare cost report settlement errors that MACs later corrected
Published November 15, 2026 · Coverage November 8–14, 2026, Pacific · Lower priority
OIG posted audit OAS-25-06-154 on November 10, 2026 (issued November 6). Summarizing six earlier audits, OIG found 234 cost report reopenings caused by Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) errors in audits or desk reviews, with corrected final settlements totaling $31.6 million: $23.3 million in overpayments and $8.3 million in underpayments. CMS's quality assurance process had identified only 8 of those cost reports. OIG recommended that CMS strengthen quality assurance, require MACs to report annually on the numbers and types of final-settlement errors, and have MACs create a quality assurance review of cost reports that had an audit or desk review only. CMS concurred with the second recommendation only.

Background
MACs perform audits and desk reviews of the annual cost reports Medicare-certified providers submit, and reopen final settlements to correct errors. This report rolls up the results of six previous OIG audits of reopened and corrected settlements.
Who this affects
Hospitals and other Medicare providers that file cost reports, and their Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs).
Why it matters
If CMS acts on the annual error reporting it agreed to, MACs may track settlement errors more closely, which could mean more reopenings of final settlements in either direction (inference). Errors run both ways, so a settlement can be reopened to pay a provider as well as to recover.
Recommended action
- Review recent notices of program reimbursement for MAC adjustments that look wrong and track reopening deadlines.
Scope and timing
- Authority status
- Other (OIG audit report with recommendations to CMS)
- Responsible owner
- Reimbursement; Finance
- Publication date
- 2026-11-10
- Other dates
- Issued 2026-11-06 (report page)
Not established
The six underlying audits and the contractors they covered were not reviewed.
Sources
Complete edition and supplemental material
This article in the complete report →
Executive triage, source-coverage limitations, context and forward horizons remain in the complete report.
Read the entire Medicare & Medicaid Sweep report →